This is a placeholder text
Group text
by Phil Behun on 22 November 2010 - 02:11
by Kalibeck on 22 November 2010 - 02:11
by shrewsbai on 22 November 2010 - 06:11
by Phil Behun on 22 November 2010 - 07:11
by sting369 on 22 November 2010 - 07:11
by LadyFrost on 22 November 2010 - 14:11
shrewsbai..ok, it sounds like you want to either replace him or place him up for adoption...have you tried contacting breeder you bought him from? most breeders will take their dogs back..you may be able to trade him for a passive/submissive female... it just seems like at some point you became his versus he is yours...
besides being 17..(most of us here are a bit older) you yourself have not been developed as a person, you have not had your will power tested, you have not had to make life changing decision, it will all come in time...there is so much scary crap out there in the world, you don't need a scary dog on top of that...you don't need to develop involuntary scared reflexes every time you see a GSD...when I was 15 I got chased by a black bull...i had to hop on top of porter potty while that thing hit and circled it...its been a long time but my heart skips a beat every time i see black bull...even though logically i know it wont hurt me, i am either in a car or on the other side of the fence, but i still get that jerk in the pit of my stomach...childhood fears or uncertainties tend to stick...i bet now when you walk into your mothers house your heart is already racing and you are on defense...am I right?
So, contact breeder and see if you can pay difference and trade...or get older dog that does not have aggression issues...you really don't need this at your age...
by loureed on 22 November 2010 - 17:11
by alboe2009 on 23 November 2010 - 03:11
Its amazing to me to see that there are "two worlds" in the dog ownership arena. One that trains, works and uses their dogs as tools etc; and the other where the dog (and no not just GSDs) but any dog is just there, an ornament, up on the counter, sitting at the dinner table with it's own plate etc.
I don't state that I know everything, all the ins and outs, whys and why nots. And having multiple dogs you'll notice the differences and the likes but I try to ask people "What do want and intend for this dog to do or to do for you? The bond has to be establish....... No partial, no halfway. Maybe she can take a little video clip of how things happen when they are together? Does the police officer (is he a friend or strictly a professional someone introduced) does he take "hands on" ? If so what is his take, remedy?
There are so many variables involved; you, the dog, his lines etc. Did you get the dog at 8 wks? or just now after a year? For me I'm partial................When I get an animal let alone a dog I make a vow to keep that dog for life. No matter how difficult times may become or circumstances arise. I had a set of Chows and said I would wait til they passed before getting GSDs again, Didn't want to show a preference. And that pair lived 17 yrs, traveled New Mexico, all over Europe, Germans loved them, Michigan and ended up in Maryland. It was rough being in the military having them but I'm glad I did it. And now I have three GSDs and hopefully in a few months a breeding?
You stated you had GSDs before? What happened to them? How were they to you? Did you have them there whole lives? If It was me (just my way of thinking) not sure if it would be different being a girl. But I would put a muzzle on him, attempt to have an understanding. Do some serious BONDING. To me Holding back food is a double edge sword. But you are after resuts I would hope? Id have an understanding and if need be, if you're strong enough, some wall to wall counseling! It's not going to happen overnight AND you have to want it. For the long haul, consistency, consistency and then more consistency. Unless he has some mental issues a light bulb is going to turn on and he sees you being the master. AS LONG AS YOU ARE!
by Don Corleone on 23 November 2010 - 03:11
by mklevin on 24 November 2010 - 21:11
I agree with Phil.
Most everyone on here (boy that's gonna tick some people off :)) that are offering training advice are offering bad advice.
Bottom line, you can't train a dog via long distane. The OP's statement of aggression may not even be correct.
The only instance listed so far by the OP is:
"i went down to say hi and open his gate and he growled and snapped at me and I backed off and he put his ears down and started panting."
Sure doesn't sound like aggression. There are also multiple comments of the dog trying to be dominant. There is no anecdotal evidence of dominance from the OP either.
Trying to give advice without understanding the dynamics of what's going on is dangerous. If this dog is defensive, nervy or even just body sensitive trying to put a muzzle on him could be disasterous for the OP. Esp. if they don't know how to fit a muzzle properly.
Uber's comments are predicated by what has worked for her without knowing what this dog's real issues are and what the OP's abilities are to read and react to any dog.
Sting's comments are straight from a book and Sting is dead wrong. People do get hurt far too often from mishandled dogs. Sometimes very seriously. You can read a book. You can not learn to read a dog from a book. You cannot learn to train a dog from a book. Sting's comments about effectively stoping the aggression comes without knowing how ugly it can get. Tom Trainor years ago had a dog tear him up and hospitalize him. That's just one example. I know of many others where individuals didn't listen and got themselves into situations where they were seriously hurt. Junks of tissue missing from their arms. Surgery, rehabilitation and long lasting deficits in motion and strength. It IS a serious issue and not something to be played with by a 6th grader.
Wall to wall counseling isn't going to cut it either. The OP has the right idea. Find this dog the right foster home where he can be correctly evaluated and worked with.
There are plenty of individuals and groups who do this kind of work. The OP just needs to find one (if the breeder is unable/unwilling) to take their dog.
More than my .02.
Matt
Contact information Disclaimer Privacy Statement Copyright Information Terms of Service Cookie policy ↑ Back to top