This is a placeholder text
Group text
by Tbay on 15 June 2006 - 19:06
Hi all,
I'm looking for information about this judges tendencies. Does anyone know if he is "working dog friendly"? There is a regional show coming up that he is the judge for, ...I'd like to know if I should try for my show rating under him or save my money and wait for another time.
Thanks for any advice.
by eichenluft on 15 June 2006 - 20:06
If you are talking working-line dogs, no he is not a judge I would enter under (with a working-line dog). In the show I was in , he put the working-line dogs at the end of the line first thing, put them outside the ring for go-away and come-back gaiting (and never watched them go/come) and then gave them all G KKl-2. Not saying he won't pass a working-line dog, but you won't be getting KKl-1 under him, in my experience (with a working-line dog)
by Tbay on 15 June 2006 - 20:06
Thanks Eichenluft,
That is the advice I was looking for. My dog is definately a working line dog so I will go with your advice and wait until next time.
Are there judges that you would recommend? I've heard that Wilfried Scheld will give a working-line dog a fair evaluation and is judging at the Canadian Nationals...
by vomlandholz on 15 June 2006 - 20:06
You def. should wait. I did a dog under him 3 yrs ago. No working line at the event got better than a g, no showline got lower than an SG. I have a couple of dogs to get ratings on, but they'll wait.
by jettasmom on 15 June 2006 - 21:06
I highly recommend SV Kormeister Helmet Konig. He looks at the workingline the same as the showline. He speaks ok english and is VERY nice. I recieved a KKL1 on my working female. We will for sure have him back.
by eichenluft on 15 June 2006 - 21:06
Yes, Scheld, Seifert, Konig, Bosl - and there are a few others I'm certain I am missing, that will give as good a look to each dog regardless of working/show lines.
molly
by tcmits on 15 June 2006 - 21:06
Include Franz Peter Knaul. He is fair if the dog(s) have decent structure
by hodie on 16 June 2006 - 00:06
Peter Arth is an excellent judge. He will put a dog up regardless of working or show bloodlines if the dog is correct in structure and fit and shown well. We have had him for a show here.
Helmut König is also an excellent judge and two years ago put several sables in the front of the class when they were correct and fit and were shown properly. He will be judging our trial, show and breed survey June 24 and 25 (next weekend) in Colorado.
by grimmdog on 16 June 2006 - 01:06
We had Johannes Grewe and were very pleased with him. He was a very nice man and showed no unfair biases at all. Should definitely consider him.
by Sieger on 16 June 2006 - 07:06
Hi,
you can show your dog under Peter Arth. He is very well know and correct judge.
regards,
Sieger
Contact information Disclaimer Privacy Statement Copyright Information Terms of Service Cookie policy ↑ Back to top
