Questions about my girls weight - Page 1

I've always thought she seems too slim and even when i've been out walking with her and people have commented that she is too skinny. The vet did say if your not use to a young gsd you might think their under-fed dogs but i just wanted to make sure that i wasnt just taken the vets word for it.

Her hips are really boney esp when you stroke her and her ribs sometimes show. God knows how my photos i have deleted cause she just looks too thin.

As far as people commenting that she is too skinny, the average person doesn't really know that dogs, especially the larger breeds, should be kept on the lean side for health purposes. My vet says that most people keep their dogs too fat and he is fanatical about educating them about proper weight. Being fat is as bad for dogs as it is for people.
 
It is hard to tell for certain, based on the photos, but she really does look fine. If she is as boney as you say, then increase her food a little.