housebreaking an adult kennel dog - Page 1

I've only had experience housebreaking one adult dog and found it to be a real challenge. Took almost 2 months. (I think now it could have been part of the reason the dog was for sale.) Is this typical or does it just depend on the dog? I'd much rather housebreak a puppy as they seem to catch on a lot faster, at least I've had pretty good luck with the pups.

It can be challenging, and a bit depending on the dog. Once you do manage to housebreak them, if for a short period keep them as a kennel dog thereafter, you may have to train them again. I've raised several pups who NEVER ONCE relieved themselves in the home (whelping box excluded)., and can maintain this habit even after long being a "mostly kennel dog".

Ranger was kept outdoors on a chain. When I adopted him, I think he had two or three accidents in the house, and THAT WAS IT! A lot depends on the dog. Some train quickly, some are much slower to learn. The basic rule is don't let them out of your sight. If possible, attach the dog's leash to your waist. The more time you can devote to housebreaking, the faster it will come. Since mature dogs sniff around more before going, that makes it a bit easier. Puppies just squat and let fly, and it's over before you can get them to the door...

I've always had better luck with females. Males seem to not care where they squat.Even with "good boy" etc.

I had better luck with my male. Bought him at 2 yrs after spending most of his life as an outside dog either running loose or at the end of a chain. BUT he was housebroke and crate trained as a pup. He just turned 4 and has never had an accident in the house. The female was another story. She was a yr old when I got her and afraid to even come in the house. When I finally convinced her it was okay to be in the house, she must have figured then it must be okay to relieve myself in the house, too. The first time I scolded her for messing in the house the poor girl cowered with a look of fear in her eyes I had never seen in a dog before. That's why I figured she must have been abused. So had to housebreak her using only positive reinforcement. Took lots and lots and lots of time and patience. Most of the trained dogs live in kennels so was wondering what I will be in for next time around.

Seems to be one of the most frequent concerns when regarding the pros/cons of puppy vs. adult when choosing a prospect. I think if you decide on an adult, a "trial period" would sure be a great opportunity to test "trainability" before committing to a purchase.