comment on my dog please - Page 3

If this forum only should contain lies and happy comments it shouldn`t be possible to post comments at all. And if you Don are honest and thinks this dog is nice, i really think you should read the GSD standars. Or maybe your just a big liar and don`t think the man deserves your honest opinion.

He wanted comments on his dog, and i told him mine. This is based on the showdogs today. I am a little bit shocked that you all think it is so beautifull, and i really think a hole lot of you are full of lies.

I also said that the important thing is that the dog is good for the owner, and that he loves the dog. But to the rest of you, act like grown ups and respect that i don`t share your point of view. This is nothing personal anyway.

My dogs name is Kaiser av Thorarinn and Cash vom Zidena, and is in the database so you can look it up. Lets see some pictures of your dog(s) Don C.

Sorry to the owner if he did get hurt by my comment, that was not my intension. I was only beeing honest.

Thorninmyside

I don't have a problem with you giving your opinion.  I only asked that you elaborate on your opinion.  You cant just tell someone that their dog sucks and not say why.  That is why I asked you to tell me, or him, your standards and how his dog is at fault. 

I stated in my post that I am not a show person and looks are not at the top of my list.  Sure, I like a good looking dog, but if it has a bad Temp, nerves, grip and can't work worth a damn, then it is garbage to me.   I go by working standards first, structure second. 

The best piece of advice I ever got regarding critiquing dogs was - any fool can fault judge a dog. Find the good things first and then state the negatives and why they are negatives in  your opinion. The photos that prasac submitted are not of the quality to pass judgement on his dog one way or the other. I certainly see no reason to say this dog sucks based on the photos on this thread and I wouldn't use that term in respect to anyone's dog.

Frankly it takes a lot of guts to ask for opinions of dogs (or anything else) on this board.  I'd never do it.