workingline best new stud - Page 21

You guys need to take this private.

You have made your points and now lets get back on topic.

Others do not want to wade through your back and forth banter.

Regards,
GSD
Site moderator

I THOUGHT THIS WAS ABOUT STUD DOGS NOT PERSONEL GRUDGES AGAINST ONEANOTHER.HOW LONG YOU GOING TO LET THIS CONTINUE GSD? AS FAR  AS TITLES. SOME OF OUR DOGS DONT HAVE TITLES AND THEY PRODUCE SOME OF THE BEST WORKING  DOGS AROUND. THEY GET A TITLE AND IT IS ACCOMPIED WITH A BADGE. WE ALSO HAVE TITLED DOGS AS WELL AND AS FAR AS TITLES,      TITLES MEAN NOTHING ABOUT BREED WORTHYNESS. IN MY HONEST OPINION I THINK IT IS NOT GOOD AS IT PUTS TOO MUCH EMPHASIS ON PREY. TAKE THE SLEEVE AWAY AND MOST WON'T BITE FOR REAL,.IT IS A GAME THEY ENJOY PLAYING.THIS IS NOT TRUE WITH A VERY SELECT FEW.

On track with the OT....
What about: Atze von Schattig Geholtz Sch3, IPO3, FH2
He resides at Hillview Kennels.
I find him very interesting, and consider him on the list for future stud possibilites for my WL females.
Anyone have experience with his progeny?

 You've been repeatedly warned, Jeff, to take it private.

The post you reference doesn't mention you at all yet you immediately admit that the person displaying their "personal grudges" is you.

Not sure how all these threads get to be a personal issue as it's sad that you all find it so compelling to prove your knowledge, experience, blah blah blah.  Do you all not realize how immature you all behave.
So, seeing how I feel so left out on my above sentences, I'll chime in. LMAO (even I have a little immaturity)...
Not defending anyone, but I have seen Eagle and Bandit work and they are (were) impressive.  They both are true to their work and temperament.  Yes, I do have an Eagle son, who works at home just the way I want, but never pursuing any SchH titles because he just doesn't care for it. Dogs are no different than us...we have our likes and dislikes.  Speaking of titles, I'm not a huge believer on titled parents because my very own working police dog was from two untitled parents.  
With all this said, I don't think it's appropriate to judge a dog without seeing it for your self.  Poor dog, can't defend itself through the Internet.  Before bashing a dog based on it's titles, lack of titles, or because of it's owner, just go watch the dog, then place have at it.
Well, that's my immaturity for the evening.   

Looking at the list presented earlier, I see a lot of commonly notable "greats" behind them.  We often hear that you "shouldn't put too much emphasis on the pedigree", which may be right.  But I would also add, don't put too little emphasis either!  You can't make wine from water alone.



1) Aceofnike van het Bleekhof Fado

2) Timmy vom Zollernblut Quasy/Nick, 3-4 Timmy

3) Iwo vom Hunxer Wald 3-4 on Troll

4) Wasko vom Eifelgrund Troll

5) Campino vom Münzspiel Troll, Arek, Fado

6) Eick von der berger Hochburg Yoschy>Troll, Fado, Half>Timmy

7) Hannes vom Spadener Holz Troll-K, Fado

8) Vito vom Waldwinkel TomV/Fado

9) Max Tiekerhook Nick>Half>Timmy, Arek, Yoschy>Troll, Fero

10) Eliot von Prevent Yoschy

11) Bandit vom Wolfsheim Vito (TomV/Fado)


Most Recurring Ancestors in Common: Fado, Nick>Half>Timmy, Yoschy>Troll, Vito>TomV

 Quote: You've been repeatedly warned, Jeff, to take it private.

So, you are a moderator ? 

Daryl, nice list. That should help out new people a lot, they don't have to spend hours looking up pedigrees to figure this out. That stuff is a bit much to remember when you are new.