2014 SV BSZS in Nuremberg video - Page 2

2014 SV BSZS Nurnberg TSB-Überprüfung Rüden (GHKR) part 2 V1-V10 

V2 1171  Sunyi vom Hühnegrab  

Victoria Graham  Paderborn  D 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh 3)

V3 1078  Quoran d' Ulmental  
Daniele Francioni  Montecatini-Terme (PT)  I 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh 3)

V4 1050  Groovy di Casa Massarelli  
Andrea Massarelli  Acquasparta (TR)  I 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh 3)

V6 1182  Yuri vom Osterberger-Land  

Dirk Wortmann  Lotte  D 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 4, Abverh 5)

V9 1210  Memphis vom Solebrunnen  

Michaela Maier-Havelkova  Lauterbach  D 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh 3)

V10 1173  Finn vom Zellwaldrand  
Ralf Wiesner  Striegistal  D 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 5, Abverh 4)

Susie,

I can see Memphis wasn't as strong as others, but can you explain to me how the judge gives the marks/grading ? In other words what did Memphis do or not do that his marks were lowest ?

Agree with susie re. the poor performances by some of the VAs (note: I DO think that on the whole the performance is improving).  Sorry, no excuses at this level.  Yes a dog can have a bad day but look at past videos of the dogs....

Thank you Irina and Sergey for your time to post these for all to see...

I thank you also.  Thank you  thank you THANK YOU...  Nan

It was really nice to see the VA's actually do a controlled heel to the blind.  Clearly they are capable.

Schumann did not deserve a VA rating...Sabaat was on the edge and at best deserved a 3-3

2014 SV BSZS Nurnberg TSB-Überprüfung Rüden (GHKR) part 3 V11-V20 

V13 1136  Kinan v. Yarek  

Budiman Salihin  Wetter  D 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh 3)

V14 1047  Willas vom Grafenbrunn  
Luigi Paesano  Quarto (Neapel)  I 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 4, Abverh 4)

V15 1065  Sony dei Colli Storici  
Nicola Bombana  Guidizzolo (MN)  I 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 5, Abverh 4)

V16 1094  Turko de Gold Shark  
Silvia Olalla Batan Veiga  Teo (Coruna)  E 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh 4)

V17 1055  Ken vom Team Baierblick  
Toni Strelow  Gehaus  D 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh 3)

V19 1034  Maffey vom Quartier Latin  

Frank Maxein  Neuwied  D 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh 3)

2014 SV BSZS Nurnberg TSB-Überprüfung Rüden (GHKR) part 4 V21-V30

V22 1112  Wesly von der Orangerie  

Andre Ehrig  Fulda  D 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh )

V24 1018  Jehu Primo Grande  

Imran Husain  Karachi, Clifton  PK 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh 3)

V25 1079  Team Leiksaid Kapitan  
Klaus Sievers  Denkendorf-Dörndorf  D 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 4, Abverh 4)

V26 1172  Dasty von Melanchthon  
Helmut König  Eppelborn  D 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 4, Abverh 4)

V27 1045  Basko della Real Favorita  
Rosario Citarda  Palermo  I 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh 3)

V28 1186  Caruso vom Frankengold  
Sven Dittrich  Frankenthal  D 
Ausgepragt, laßt ab (Überfall 3, Abverh 3)

FWIW from an AKC person, I get the impression that a helper can easily add or subtract from the scores  by the way he handles the sleeve when the dog first attempts to engages him.  I understand the protection phase is a vital part of the judging process, but wonder if it really tells as much about each dog as the scores indicate?  Before I get thrown under the bus, I'm not suggesting that has happened on any of these videos, just making an observation from the peanut gallery.

Also a few questions, how bad is it for the dog to keep looking back at it's handler? Why do some do that? I understand about being dirty on the sleeve, but how most of this bitework is scored puzzles me to be truthful. If a dog doesn't take a full bite becase the sleeve is moved away from him just as he engages the helper, what does that say about the dog?

Also, could the skill of the trainer be as vital to a good score as the dog itself? I'm not nearly as well versed in protection as most here, but I'd really have to be more convinced that the scoring of the bitework at a Seiger show should be a big factor to me when choosing a stud dog or a puppy. How many of the 3-3 dogs will be sold in the next months and how much will those scores influence the breeding programs and the prices of puppies? Might be some good buys in Germany this month?